Explore Close
Menu Close

Categories

BlogArticlesSpeechesInterviewsEssaysBook ReviewsLetters

Tags

International developmentIraqUK PoliticsLabour PartyMiddle Eastbiographyextractive industriesIsrael-PalestineAfricaeconomicsreligion and ethicsurbanisationglobalisationenvironmentforeign policyforeign aidChilcot ReportBrexitfeminismEU

Archives

October 2022 August 2022 November 2021 July 2021 March 2021 February 2021 October 2020 July 2020 June 2020 May 2020 April 2020 February 2020
  • Blog
  • Articles
  • Speeches
  • Interviews
  • Other Writings
    • Essays
    • Books
    • Book Reviews
    • Letters
  • About
    • Biography
    • Current Work
    • Gallery
  • Contact

Clare Short

Clare Short

  • Blog
  • Articles
  • Speeches
  • Interviews
  • Other Writings
    • Essays
    • Books
    • Book Reviews
    • Letters
  • About
    • Biography
    • Current Work
    • Gallery
  • Contact
Articles

Radical Ed Miliband.

The current, broken political system prevents a radical social democratic agenda from gaining a foothold. Should Miliband take office he will quickly realise his limitations.

thomas_admin on 21st August 2013
Article originally published in Prospect Magazine | 21-August-2013

Does the improving UK economy mean that Ed Miliband’s chances of winning power have lessened? In fact improvements in output exist alongside​Miliband is a thoughtful and radical politician, if rather young and untried, trapped in a system that prevents him from being distinctive and speaking about the big, longer-term questions. declining incomes. Those with high mortgages benefit from low interest rates but this will change. Currently lower income households and the young suffer most. We have heard about the squeezed middle and One Nation Labour, but it isn’t clear what that means. For a time, Labour’s economic policy seemed to be, “cut a little less.” Now it is, “stick with government targets.” There is little reason to think much would change with a Miliband government, and that is his major problem.

Yet there is a deep unease with politics and foreboding about the future. Why can’t Labour capitalise on this? It is partly the memory of New Labour, but also the use of polling, focus groups and soundbites, that make long-term policy thinking impossible. Thus the political elite herd onto the same, safety-first space and disconnect more and more from the rest of us.

​Miliband is a thoughtful and radical politician, if rather young and untried, trapped in a system that prevents him from being distinctive and speaking about the big, longer-term questions. It would frighten too many (not least the Blairites) to set out a radical new agenda. But, he must challenge the narrative on Labour spending. This should perhaps be led from the backbenches, calling for a more grown-up debate and admission that any responsible government had to save the banks and therefore increase debt. Then Miliband should put together emblematic commitments that can be implemented quickly, complemented by longer-term strategies.​

The issue causing most damage is inequality. Changes to the benefits systems cannot be the answer. Brown brought in working family tax credits and subsidies for escalating rents, but this drives up the welfare budget and does not reduce underlying inequality. Britain has become one of the most unequal countries in the OECD. This creates an unhappy society and a huge welfare bill. Miliband should rally support for the living wage, call for more technical training for working-class jobs and then establish a Royal Commission on reducing inequality

On Europe, Labour is saying nothing distinctive. There is a problem with the European Commission’s instinct to regulate everything and ignore the principle of subsidiarity. But the new issue is the relationship of non-euro members to the EU. Miliband should promise to work with this group to thrash out a new relationship with the eurozone. We need to retain the benefits of the single market but allow real subsidiarity.

New Labour managerialism and creeping commercialisation of the public sector has damaged pride in public service. The school system, for example, is now a test and exam passing system that delivers poor quality education. In the health service, targets and financial incentives prioritise too much activity that is unrelated to providing care or preventing ill health. Miliband should promise collaborative reviews to minimise targets and build long-term consensus, rather than endless Secretary of State initiatives.

On foreign policy, acting as a constant echo of the US humiliates Britain and means we contribute little to the future stability of the world. The UK needs to sometimes act independently, for example looking for a coalition of the willing on Israel/Palestine, based on respect for international law. On asylum, there needs to be a renegotiation of the 1951 Convention: being able to pay people smugglers should not determine who can get here, but the policy should not be cruelty to those who arrive.

We must also review of the Bank of England’s quantitative easing programme. I believe it is propping up an overinflated financial sector that has lost all sense of investing in real things. I would cancel QE; there are doubts about it among financial commentators, but Labour cannot afford to spook the markets. Miliband should announce a big effort on insulation, renewables and fuel poverty as part of the growing investment in infrastructure and set up a review of QE when in power.​

Housing is another mess. Successive governments have encouraged house price inflation—too much capital is tied up in housing. Britain has shortages and outrageous rents. Miliband should commit to tax relief on low cost rental accommodation and promise to build more social housing. In office, he should create incentives to release much more of the under-occupied housing.

There is a radical social democratic agenda that would be popular, and that would work for Miliband—but the big problem is the impossibility of long-term thinking in the current political system. Coalitions should make this easier, but parties are mesmerised by polling and the newspapers that fewer and fewer people read. This is, funnily enough, Blair’s true legacy.

Read the original article from the publisher.

  • Posted in: Articles
  • Tagged in: Labour Party

Posted by

All Posts
Leave a comment Hide comments

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts

  • Sir Brian Urquhart Award acceptance speech
  • Only a new asylum convention can thwart the people smugglers
  • What’s wrong with aid? LSE lecture
  • Labour’s route to power involves coalition with smaller parties
  • The audacity of change
  • Clare’s recent lecture: Reflecting on the Demise of DfID
  • Britain’s aid budget could soon become little more than a slush fund for business

Content

  • Articles
  • Blog
  • Book Reviews
  • Essays
  • Interviews
  • Letters
  • Speeches

Tags

Afghanistan Africa anti-racism biography Birmingham Brexit Chilcot Report Cities Alliance class Cold War constitution corruption Donald Trump economics education policy electoral reform environment EU European politics extractive industries feminism foreign aid foreign policy globalisation International development international relations Iraq Irish Politics Israel-Palestine Labour Party media Middle East Oxfam publications religion and ethics resources Russia slum dwellers Syria terrorism UK Politics UN United States urbanisation US politics
Previous
Visit to Australia.
12th July 2013
Next
Labour’s prospects.
2nd September 2013

Clare Short was born in Birmingham in 1946. She became MP for Birmingham Ladywood in 1983, subsequently serving as Secretary of State for International Development (1997-2003). Since leaving Parliament she has worked as chair of numerous non-governmental advocacy groups working with communities across the developing world.

Content

  • Articles
  • Blog
  • Book Reviews
  • Essays
  • Interviews
  • Letters
  • Speeches

Recent Posts

  • Sir Brian Urquhart Award acceptance speech
  • Only a new asylum convention can thwart the people smugglers
  • What’s wrong with aid? LSE lecture
  • Labour’s route to power involves coalition with smaller parties
  • The audacity of change
  • Clare’s recent lecture: Reflecting on the Demise of DfID
  • Data Policy
  • Cookies Policy
  • Republication
  • Contact
  • | Site built by Thomas Bishop ⓒ 2020
© 2023 Paperback Theme by Array.